It's her turn to roll her eyes, but fair's fair, and she takes a drink. This is how he wants to play it, then? Fine.

She continues with more of the obvious.

"Never have I ever had a pet."
"Never have I ever had a cat." (He'll argue it's the same thing, she'll insist that it's not.)
"Never have I ever had a prosthetic limb." (She'll be nice and not overdo this one. Or say anything about adjacent topics.)
"Never have I ever been propositioned by a talking raccoon."